Dassault Rafale✈vs J20 Chengdu✈
Parameters |
Dassault Rafale |
J20 Chengdu |
Top Speed |
2,130 Km/h |
2,223 Km/h |
Range |
3,700 Km |
3,400 km |
Weight |
9,979 Kg |
19,390 Kg |
Program Cost |
US$62.7 billion |
US$4.4 billion |
Manufacturer |
Dassault Aviation |
Chengdu Aircraft Industry Group |
Engine type |
Snecma M88,Turbo fan |
Xian WS-15, Turbo fan |
Service Ceiling |
15,240 m |
18,000 m |
Max takeoff Weight |
24.5t(54,000 lbs) |
34t/37t |
Generation |
4.5th gen |
5th gen |
Now let's compare the avionics and radar of these two
aircraft china has not made the details of j-20s radar public, but if reports
are to be believed the Chinese aircraft use an active electronically scanned
array radar system a similar technology is used in the rafale as well and this
is considered to be one of the most advanced radar technologies available in
the world right now, but does that make both aircraft equal not really how
avionics and other technologies are incorporated into the aircraft makes a huge
difference one of the key technological advantages of rafale is this electronic
warfare suit spectra. This protects the aircrafts from ground and airborne
threats various methods of detection decoying jamming and highly reprogrammable
system capable of analyzing multiple threats makes it very
difficult to detect and shoot down a rafale. we are told
that 30 of the total cost of producing a rafale goes into spectra on the other
hand j20's radar is equipped with chin mounted optic infrared surge and track
sensor which gives the pilot a 360 degree view of the battlefield.
The Chinese also claim that the pilot can access
information from Chinese satellites from this fighter aircraft with
the limited information available in the public domain. It can be concluded
that both aircraft have very capable radar and avionics on board since they are
multi-role aircraft they can undertake missions like air-to-air &
air-to-ground in-depth strike anti-ship and nuclear deterrence missions and for
this they come with an array of weapons and technologies the two main weapons
that India will be getting with rafale are the scalp and a meteor while
scalp is an air-to-ground missile. Meteor is a beyond visual range air-to-air
missile once again very little credible information is available about j-20s
firepower but in case of an aerial combat these two aircrafts are likely to use
their beyond visual range missiles in India's case it is a meteor and in
china's j-20s case it is said to be the pl-15 air-to-air missile and here is
how these two missiles match up against each other the pl-15 missile has a
range exceeding 200 kilometers while the meteor exceeds a range of 150
kilometers pl 15 has a maximum speed of 49 kilometers per
hour while rafale's meteor has a speed of 4248 kilometers per
hour there is a huge difference between these two air-to-air missiles.
The pl-15 missile is designed to take down big
targets like an air-to-air refueller or an airbag. Which is an early warning
system while the meteor is capable of taking even smaller targets like a cruise missile or a
UAV even though in terms of speed and range meteor lags this advantage gives it
an extra edge. china
has claimed that j20 is a 5th generation
aircraft with stealth capabilities in layman's language stealth capability
means that the design of an aircraft makes it difficult for an enemy radar to
pick it up does that mean that the j20 has an advantage over rafale on this
front to understand this we need to look at two different aspects according to
reports the design of the j20 is highly influenced by another fifth generation
aircraft the f-22 raptor which is used by the united states there are reports
that in 2009 during an exercise a rafale was able to track and target an f-22
at the same time the Indian air force has claimed that his su-30 MKIs were able
to track j-20s along the Chinese border during its sorties now rafale doesn't
have stealth technology it is a 4.5 generation fighter plane but it has been
designed in such a way that the radar cross-section of this aircraft is much
less compared to the other aircraft operational in the world right now coupled
with spectra rafale still has a good chance against the stealth technology of
the Chinese j-20 while comparing these two aircraft it is very important to understand
the operational history of these two fighter plates the rafale has proven its
capabilities in many battlefields including in Libya Iraq Afghanistan and many
other African countries where the French air force has been deployed but on the
other hand the j-20 does not have any operational history that proves the
capabilities of the Chinese claim to have the Quinn spoke with several experts
to understand the key differences between these two aircraft and a common theme
that emerged from this conversation was the fact that j20's capabilities are
merely on paper yes the Chinese have managed to develop a fifth generation
airframe but the fact that the Indian air force fighters can pick them on their
radar shows that the claims aren't true as they claim to be it is highly
possible that the j20 is not a fifth generation aircraft at all at the same
time India's new purchase the rafale is a 4.5 generation and a highly capable
aircraft which has proven itself on several battlefields considering these fact
it is possible that the rafale is as good as a j-20 even though that is claimed
to be a fifth generation fighter aircraft
🙏
ReplyDeleteNoice
ReplyDeleteWhat does this mean 😂 will you plz elaborate
DeleteContent is Worthy
ReplyDeleteGreat...
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete